What Do You Really Think?

Progress and the Fear of Criticism

I was hoping for more. A recent survey of area sustainability-related blogs, particularly those that offer some type of analysis, criticism or reflection, turned up few. Of what exists, most are announcement focused. Critical analysis of sustainability related initiatives doesn’t occur in a public sphere. If it does happen, it goes on in private, behind backs, more partially-informed gossip than knowledgeable analysis. If we take sustainable innovation seriously, there should be a forum in which projects are unpacked and examined in an effort to develop the practice. I would be the first to submit our projects to review. The longer I’m engaged with this work, the more dedicated I have become to the longer arc of maturing this still-emerging field. Each undertaking should be another step up the ladder, rather than the same first step. Way too often projects are repeating the latter. Significant progress—what exactly that means is a subject for another time—depends on a lot more than what I, or any other single practitioner, has to offer. Mustering the courage, trust and humility to open our undertakings to examination, or to review those of others, is its own challenge.

Peter Nicholson, Innovationist

More from Essay

What Can You See From Here?

Sleeping With Volcanoes Everyone should watch this video. It brilliantly and hilariously contextualizes our efforts to “save the planet.” Last week, I trekked around two dormant volcanoes, one near Santa Fe, and the other Seattle. Physically dramatic, they are even more

What’s Our Carrot?

When the Inconvenient Truth Becomes Inconvenient We fantasized about ice cream. After a grey and wet five-day backpacking expedition through the tundra of Alaska, we were ready for a treat. This last day was the most difficult, with periods of

Part II: The Promise of Youth?

The Revelation Equation He looked concerned. More accustomed to addressing high-level leaders, my prominent environmentalist friend wasn’t sure how to address a class of teenagers. “How much should I tell them?,” he asked, taking me aside a few minutes before

Part I: How to Temper the Future?

Crashing the Party with Constraints I lit a fire. It was simple: ask a group of teenagers gathered from across the country to design an “iPhone 8.” The previously subdued group exploded, with rapid-fire ideas quickly filling the classroom’s white

What If I Didn’t Know?

Envy for the Unexamined World I checked out. Earlier this month, for a few days at least, I was able to take a break…from caring. Though a short vacation, the diversion nonetheless provided the opportunity to suspend focusing on the

Is This Necessary?

(Boring) Prerequisites for Success “Give me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening the axe.”  -A. Lincoln Prerequisites matter. I’m hunkered down trying to make progress on a variety of long-deferred organizational

Can This Be Improved?

Why Yes, Yes It Can I’ve started catching up. I’ve abandoned the fantasy that I’ll ever get everything done. Having more to do gets me up in the morning. The trick is not to miss anything important. In this way,

How Content Are You?

The Summer of Our Dissatisfaction Discontent is essential. Innovation is inhibited by satisfaction with the status quo. My work is about identifying potential, expeditions into the fertile no man’s land between what is and what could be. Realizing this future,

What Do They Need to Know?

My Response to Climate Change I made it. The last six weeks of teaching three different cohorts of teens about sustainable innovation has left me exhausted and energized. There hasn’t bee one defining moment, but rather a series of them.